Grilled Pimento Cheese Sandwiches

We handpicked the products and tools linked in this post. If you buy from one of these affiliate links, we may earn a small commission. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Are you craving a hot sandwich that's pure comfort food?  Try our pimento cheese sandwich recipe. 

This sandwich is made with our homemade pimento spread and is topped with crispy bacon and grilled until golden brown, so the outside is crunchy and the inside full of melted cheese.

Jump to:

• Ingredients
• Questions
• Serve
• How to Make
• Variations
• Pro Tips
• Recommended Tools
• Recipe

Want to see our latest recipes?  Subscribe to our email newsletter to get our latest recipes, fun food facts, food puns, and behind the scenes news about our blog.

Ingredients

• Cooked Vegetables: caramelized onions, collard greens, or fried green tomatoes
• Fresh Vegetables: tomato slices, lettuce
• Pickled Vegetables: dill pickle coins, jalapeños, giardiniera
• Meat: crispy bacon, fried chicken tenders
• Spicy/Smoky: chipotle peppers in adobo sauce
• Jelly: pepper jelly

Questions

What kind of bread is used?

• Use bread cut in ½ inch slices
• Sourdough bread
• Brioche bread
• Texas toast

How do you cut this sandwich?

• Let the grilled sandwich rest 5 minutes before cutting.
• Cut in half for a casual look.
• Cut in triangles, squares, or fingers for a fancier look.

What is the calories for one serving?

If you use our homemade pimento spread, there is 668 calories for ½ of a large sandwich.  This sandwich is high in vitamins A and C and has 22.6g of protein.  For more nutritional information, scroll to the end of the recipe card.

How can I make this recipe vegan?

Make the following substitutions.

• Use vegan friendly mayo.
• Use vegan cheddar shreds.
• Use 2 cups canned chickpeas, drained and smashed, along with 2 tablespoons of nutritional yeast.

Can you make this ahead of time?

It's best to grill the sandwiches just before eating, but you can have the spread made ahead of time. 

Want to make this extra melty and hot?

• Place grilled  sandwiches on a baking tray.
• Place them in a 350 F oven until the cheese melts more and the sandwiches are heated through.

How can I make this in bulk?

• Use mayo instead of butter; it spreads faster.  Use 1 tablespoon per sandwich.
• Use two large rimmed baking sheets that are the same size.
• Preheat one of the baking sheets on the middle rack in a 450F oven.
• Place 6 sandwiches on the bottom (unheated) baking tray.
• Place the preheated baking sheet on top of the sandwiches.
• Bake on the middle rack in a 450 F oven for 15 minutes or until golden brown.

Can you reheat this recipe?

Yes, you can.  It's best to reheat the sandwich in a skillet over medium high heat for 30 seconds to one minute.

Can you freeze leftovers?

It's not advisable since the oil in the mayo will separate when frozen.

Serve

• Soup: tomato
• Fried vegetables: okra, green tomatoes
• Pickled vegetables: pickle spears, jalapenos coins
• Cooked vegetables: collard greens
• Fresh vegetables: tomatoes
• Crunchy/Salty: potato chips
• Beverage: fresh brewed sweet tea

How to Make

Gather the four ingredients: homemade pimento cheese spread, bacon, butter, and sliced sourdough bread.

Cook the bacon in a large cast iron skillet over medium heat until crispy, flipping with a fork when the first side is done.  Pour the bacon grease into a bowl and place in your fridge for another use.

Transfer the bacon to a paper towel-lined plate and blot with another paper towel to remove extra grease.

Measure out two tablespoons of spread for each slice of sourdough bread. 

Make sure not to spread it right to the edge.  There needs to be some room for the pimento cheese to spread out when it is melted.

Add 2 or 3 slices of crispy bacon on top of the spread.

Place the top slice of sourdough bread on the bottom slice.

Butter the top and bottom slices of the bread.

Melt the butter in a large skillet over medium high heat, than swirl it around the skillet until the bottom is well covered.

Grill the bread over medium heat until golden brown, roughly 2 to 3 minutes.  When ready, flip the sandwich over with a metal spatula.

Transfer the sandwich to a cutting board with the metal spatula.  Allow the sandwich to cool for 5 minutes. 

Cut the two large sandwiches in half with a sharp knife and enjoy them while they're warm.

Variations

• Crostini: Spread this on a ciabatta loaf top with bacon crumbles.  Bake on a baking sheet at 400 F for 2 minutes or until melted.
• English Muffin: Cut English muffins in half and spread pimento cheese on both halves.  Bake under the broiler for 5 minutes.
• Don't want to use butter?  Try spreading mayo on the outside of the bread before grilling.
• Want a different fat for grilling?  Use bacon grease instead of butter.
• Want to use nuts as a topping?  Try toasted chopped pecans.
• Need topping ideas?  Try pickled jalapeños, pickled banana peppers, sliced tomatoes, or lettuce.
• Want to add cooked veggies?  Try putting homemade collard greens, that are well drained, or fried green tomatoes on top of the bacon.

Pro Tips

• Want to save some calories?  Don't spread butter on the outside of the bread; just toast it in a skillet with a little butter or bacon grease.
• Need a bread tip?  Use bread that is thick enough, so it won't fall apart when flipped or picked up.
• When is it best to cut the sandwich?  It cuts the best after it has rested for 5 minutes.
• Need to make lots of sandwiches?  Keep them warm in a 350 F oven; it will also melt the pimento cheese more.
• Use homemade pimento cheese spread; it tastes better and is easy to make.

Recommended Tools

• Emeril 3-Quart Skillet: this heavy-bottomed skillet is perfect for grilling sandwiches.
• Lodge 10-Inch Skillet: we love frying bacon in this sturdy cast iron skillet.
• 11x17-Inch Cookie Sheets: use these trays to keep the sandwiches warm in the oven.
• Bamboo Cutting Board: assemble and serve the sandwiches on this pretty board.
• Metal Spatula: this thin metal spatula makes it easy to flip the sandwiches.

Make other delicious Southern sandwiches with these recipes.

• Pimento Cheese Spread
• Pulled Pork Sandwiches
• Muffaletta Sandwich

The pleasure of a 5-star review would be greatly appreciated.

Print

Recipe